Author Box
Articles Categories
All Categories
Articles Resources

Labor and Management Form Coalition to Stabilize Workers' Compensation Costs

April 13, 2012 | Comments: 0 | Views: 149

A coalition is an alliance among individuals or groups, during which they cooperate in joint action, each in their own self-interest, joining forces together for a common cause. Labor and management in the building trades of West Virginia have done exactly that in their joint effort to control the costs of workers' compensation insurance. Recognizing the benefits of training, drug testing, and proactive communication in the objective of reducing workers' compensation injuries, labor and management have combined efforts and created an insurance program that returns the benefits of reduced workers' compensation losses. The insurance program is known as a Group Captive, and it not only provides the essential coverage for workers compensation but rewards participants with superior training and loss prevention.

The Alliance

Too often the discussion in the media on the topic of labor and management is focused on their conflict. Disagreements surrounding collective bargaining, organizing, political fundraising, benefits, and foreign competition fill the papers. After a heavy dose of this conflict, it's easy to forget the parties and people involved share a lot in common. The craftsman is an employee of the employer contractor. In other words, they work at the same company with common goals and objectives. Both work together in bidding and completing a construction project that offers compensation and personal satisfaction. Each gain when the project is completed timely and under budget; the contractor employer through profits and the tradesman through improved wages and benefits. It is undeniable that when construction projects are not profitable, labor and management both lose.

When the employer and its employee look for ways to work together in an effort to jointly improve their self interest, the cost of operating the business inevitably presents itself. One operating expense where the tradesman and contractor can come together is workers' compensation insurance. The expense of funding losses arising from injured workers is no small part of a contractors operating budget. This is especially true for contractors employing the building trades whose skill and training demand a higher wage. With workers' compensation insurance premium determined by multiplying a premium rate by payroll, union contractors pay more for workers' compensation insurance than their competitors employing lower wage non-union labor even though union tradesmen's training and focus on safety would suggest a more attractive claim outcome. The insurance pricing anomaly union contractors present can be mitigated when labor and management cooperatively share risk through a Group Captive.

Joining Forces

Even before the Group Captive was implemented, the building trades in West Virginia joined forces with contractors in the development of a first class training program in response to claim activity on the individual job sites. The claim activity monitoring started as a method to quantify the benefits of and need for specific training topics. Certified, experienced experts regularly provide hands on instruction to apprentice as well as veteran craftsmen. The training includes coursework in equipment operation, safety, and loss prevention. Thousands of hours are dedicated to the development and improvement of the skills deployed on every construction project. This is unique to the union labor market as the higher wages in part fund specialized apprentice training facilities for the aforementioned trainers to educate apprentices and craftsman. Labor and management also joined forces in developing a credible drug testing program that provided both labor and management with confidence in the accuracy, fairness, and completeness of the testing. While the Department of Transportation programs test based on a five panel screen, the building trades in West Virginia perform a higher level of testing.

These programs continue to improve through regular meetings where labor and management share ideas, obstacles, and solutions for the delivery of the most effective training and safety programs available. These meetings take place at least quarterly and maintain as their objective an open dialogue on the challenges confronting the participants. Challenges are best solved face to face with candid discussion. This works for training curriculum, drug testing, communication, and safety. In fact, the benefits from open, clear, and regular communication are further embraced by labor and management in this insurance program through the implementation of a trouble shooter.. The trouble shooter's job is to make sure the back to work, claim adjudication, fact gathering, and loss prevention programs that are available to the contractors are deployed timely and efficiently. A combined force of labor and management is focused on the reduction of workers' compensation expense.

Realize the Return

With the groundwork laid for the effective control of workers' compensation costs by labor and management's cooperative efforts, an insurance program that offered the participants the greatest return for their outstanding loss results was needed. A Group Captive offered the employer contractors the best opportunity to realize a return of underwriting and investment income from their workers' compensation premiums. A Group Captive is an insurance company that is owned and/or controlled by its insureds. In this case, the insureds are employer contractors, and they are the participants of the Group Captive.

Group Captive participants purchase insurance the same way they do in the standard market; they send in their underwriting information, receive a quote and bind coverage. A Group Captive insurance program provides the necessary infrastructure for the delivery of claim payments, including a claims administration or TPA company, an insurer to issue the policies and a reinsurer to cover the large or unforeseen loss events. The Group Captive then adds a Captive insurance facility that is controlled by the group to assume a portion of the risk that is typically retained by the insurer. The Group Captive functions like any other insurance company and reports to its owner contractors its financial performance with premium earnings, loss payments, expenses, and investment performance activity.

Through retaining risk in the Captive and the application of programs designed to prevent and reduce workers' compensation losses, the Group Captive participants may experience underwriting results enabling a return of underwriting and investment income. Without the Captive participation by the employer contractors, these positive underwriting outcomes would have inured to the benefit of the insurance company alone. The return of underwriting and investment income obviously reduces the union contractors' expense of insuring their workers' compensation and offers a cost advantage over traditional insurance coverage.

Does It Work?

The proof is in the numbers. Are the employer contractors realizing a savings over buying traditional workers compensation insurance? A review of historical premiums and losses for more than 30 different union contractors were revealing. On average, the employer contractor could realize between a 20 and 30 percent expense reduction by participating in the Group Captive. This revelation is causing the idea to flourish with more than thirty contractors applying for participation in the West Virginia Group Captive. Indeed, the Group Captive approach is spreading to neighboring states where the same labor management coalition is taking hold. An exciting development that truly can be described as a "win win" for all involved.

Roundstone Management, Ltd. ("Roundstone") based in Westlake, Ohio is a Workers Compensation Group focused on the development, underwriting and servicing of alternative risk products, including captives, rent-a-captives and specialty Workers Comp Insurance Providers. Roundstone offers intermediaries and buyers an expertise in the captive marketplace utilizing the facilities of Roundstone Insurance, Ltd.

Source: EzineArticles
Was this Helpful ?

Rate this Article

Article Tags:

Workers Comp Insurance Providers


Workers Compensation Group


Captive Insurance Company

Auto insurance is probably one of the most expensive insurance types in Canada. An average car insurance policy in Canada costs approximately $1,200 per year and in Ontario, the largest Canadian

By: Alex Saltykov l Insurance > Car Auto l July 09, 2013 lViews: 553

Your house is often your largest investment that you need to protect via insurance. We created a list of multiple savings tips related to Home insurance and hope that these will help you to save a

By: Alex Saltykov l Insurance > Home Owners Renters l December 27, 2012 lViews: 380

Most auto insurance companies design specific car insurance policies for classic and antique cars. If you think you have a classic car and want classic car insurance, you will need to be sure that

By: Richard l Insurance > Car Auto l October 17, 2012 lViews: 570

Business Overhead Expense Insurance Plans can provide cash flow to the business in the event of a disability to a key employee or owner. For a small, growing company it might make the difference

By: T. Spencer White l Insurance > Disability l July 17, 2012 lViews: 244

Workers compensation costs are rising. According to a recent report by the Workers Compensation Research Institute (WCRI), indemnity costs per claim (the loss of earning capacity, payments for lost

By: Kelly C. Williams l Insurance > Workers Compensation l July 08, 2012 lViews: 222

One of the most helpful government programs out there is the SSI Disability program. A person that is legitimately disabled, and cannot work to provide an income for themselves for their family

By: Oleg Winter-Burnett l Insurance > Disability l July 04, 2012 lViews: 282

Workers compensation costs are rising. According to a recent report by the Workers Compensation Research Institute (WCRI), indemnity costs per claim (the loss of earning capacity, payments for lost

By: Kelly C. Williamsl Insurance > Workers Compensationl July 08, 2012 lViews: 222

Engrossed indemnity companies have been a popular tax and business planning tool since many years. Earlier, only multinational firms used engrossed indemnity companies, but that concept has changed

By: Jennifer Boeriol Insurance > Workers Compensationl June 30, 2012 lViews: 180

Every business owner in the UK is governed by some regulation or other. For any business that employs staff, one of the most important regulations is actually a legal requirement as laid down in the

By: George McGonigall Insurance > Workers Compensationl June 21, 2012 lViews: 186

Income protection insurance generally provides benefit when you become unemployed temporarily due to injury, accident, or illness. Even though it covers 75% of your gross annual income, not many

By: Jeff R Triboletl Insurance > Workers Compensationl June 20, 2012 lViews: 166

A safe workplace is obviously essential for your employees' health and well-being, but it is also important when you consider the insurance costs for workers compensation. Making sure your workplace

By: Kelly C. Williamsl Insurance > Workers Compensationl June 17, 2012 lViews: 188

The very last thing you look forward to is your workers' compensation audit. It takes you at the very least a few days to assemble everything the auditor really wants to see: huge binders and stacks

By: Ellen Yeel Insurance > Workers Compensationl June 17, 2012 lViews: 190

Engrossed indemnity companies have been a popular tax and business planning tool since many years. Earlier, only multinational firms used engrossed indemnity companies, but that concept has changed

By: Jennifer Boeriol Insurance > Workers Compensationl June 30, 2012 lViews: 180

Discuss this Article

comments powered by Disqus