Author Box
Articles Categories
All Categories
Articles Resources

Why Do Bright Children Get Into Trouble?

February 15, 2012 | Comments: 0 | Views: 141

Why do bright children make poor decisions and get into trouble?

In my Speech Pathology practise I frequently meet children who are brought along because they are not achieving their potential at school. They have often had Psychology assessments that have shown that they are bright kids. But in real life they are just not functioning well.

All the language assessments can show that they have good skills in comprehension, following instructions and remembering what they hear.

So why do they often get things wrong at school and get into trouble with teachers and at home? Usually the children can't explain their choices or behaviour or lack of action. Parents are looking for answers.

So the next area I usually look at is the ability to answer questions that involve inferential reasoning. I use an assessment tool called "Test of Problem Solving", commonly known as TOPS. This test presents a child with a series of situation pictures involving other children. They are then asked a series of questions about each situation.

The answers to the questions rate a child's ability to answer questions that involve:

· Explaining inferences (for example, How do you know the boy is sick?). This skill is needed if children are going to be able to gather evidence, understand implications, realise what a situation is likely to mean or explain their own behaviour. It is also crucial for answering written questions about texts at school. If this skill is not developed children miss information, miss the main point of what they see or hear and don't understand non-literal speech such as sarcasm, jokes or figures of speech. They can misjudge other people's actions or intentions.

· Sequencing (for example, What will the dad do next?) This skill allows people to learn to plan and organise and to do tasks logically without missing out vital steps. It also ensures that children can orient their listener and tell a story that makes sense to others, rather than just launching into the middle of a story without saying when or where it happened.

· Negative questions (for example, Why wouldn't you shake his hand now?) Negative questions use more complex language than Why questions, and need a change of perspective to understand. People around us use these types of questions constantly (Why don't..?. Why shouldn't...?)

· Understanding causes (for example, What might have caused the lights in the building to go out?) Children who don't see how they got into a difficult situation often can't explain causes. So they are unlikely to learn from their mistakes. They will have difficulty answering school topics that involve, say, History or English, where they need to analyse what lead to certain events.

· Suggesting solutions (for example, What could the girl do the next day?) Some children find themselves in tricky situations and only make things worse, because they can't work out the best thing to do in the circumstances. Children (and all of us!) need to be able to evaluate a range of solutions and choose the one that will make things better, or at least stay the same, not worse.

· Preventing problems (for example, What could these children do to prevent germs from spreading in their classroom?) Often the answers to these types of questions involve children having some knowledge about the world and then being able to generalise it and apply that knowledge to specific situations. Children that don't understand about preventing problems, of course, end up in trouble frequently.

If your child has any of the difficulties discussed in this article, it is probably worth while not to simply assume that they are naughty. This may be the case, but check out whether or not they can answer these types of questions first. Behaviour management strategies may need to be put into place, but if the underlying reasons for the poor choices are not fixed then, in the long term, little is going to change.

Academically a child may progress much faster if these inferential reasoning skills are working well for them.

Source: EzineArticles
Was this Helpful ?

Rate this Article

Article Tags:

Bright Children


Inferential Reasoning






Negative Questions





Your body needs glucose in order to get energy for cell and tissue function. Without energy, the cells do not function properly and the immune system is compromised. When your blood glucose levels

By: Clifford H Woods l Health & Fitness > Diabetes l July 09, 2013 lViews: 2617

Heavy Metals - Free radicals (tissue damaging molecules that cause aging and bodily deterioration) are the result of the ever-present toxins within our environment. Heavy metals are contained in

By: Clifford H Woods l Health & Fitness > Supplements l July 09, 2013 lViews: 606

Braun shavers and trimmers are very standard brand and their new curser beard and head trimmer is big for trimming beards. This trimmer was specifically made to be able to trim down your beard and

By: Lovey Blackburn l Health & Fitness > Beauty l December 20, 2012 lViews: 459

On this website you will find latest makeup reviews and swatches from real people. You will know how makeup products look in real life, and you can also participate! Post your photos, tips and

By: l Health & Fitness > Beauty l December 09, 2012 lViews: 320

You can either seek referrals from friends and associates or search for consultants on the internet. The latter, in our opinion, would be a viable option for those pressed for time.You can either

By: Simon Liva l Health & Fitness > Diseases l December 07, 2012 lViews: 268

Healthy living is essential in today's world, to ensure one's well being. Learn how to relax and improve your mood now! Be it exercising, or indulging in one's passions and hobbies, be sure to set

By: Clarinda l Health & Fitness > Mind Body Spirit l December 02, 2012 lViews: 262

More than 70% of stutterers who undertake an intensive stuttering therapy course relapse back into stuttering fairly quickly after therapy. How can that be? Initial results are all good, and we love

By: Dave El Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl June 29, 2012 lViews: 175

Stuttering is a complex communication disorder rather than simply a speech disorder. The term, ABCs of Stuttering (A = Affective, B = Behavioural, C = Cognitive), sums up its complexity. Research

By: Dave El Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl June 29, 2012 lViews: 196

Let today be the end of procrastination of doing something about your stutter / stammer. How many times have you said to yourself, "I really have to do something about my stuttering, it's driving me

By: Dave El Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl June 28, 2012 lViews: 139

Do you have a child who cannot use his words to comment, or does not say what he wants? Info talk is a simple therapy technique that will possibly help your child to speak.

By: Angeline Sayocl Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl June 23, 2012 lViews: 158

When talking about linguistics and its diversity, there is one interesting fact. American Sign Language is actually among the most used in the world. Did you know that sign language has a grammatical

By: Syed Faran Akhtarl Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl June 17, 2012 lViews: 179

When most people think of speech therapy, they immediately think of articulation. Speech therapy involves more than just pronunciation. Speech therapy also helps people overcome communication

By: Rebecca H Haasl Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl June 17, 2012 lViews: 168

Do you want your child to be great at putting things together? How good do you want your child to be at following instructions - and giving others directions? Recent research has shown that that way

By: Adele Janel Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl March 26, 2012 lViews: 179

Parents and teachers get frustrated, understandably, when children don't do as they are told, or don't remember what they are supposed to do. The perception often is that a child "doesn't listen".

By: Adele Janel Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl February 20, 2012 lViews: 161

Dysphagia is the medical term for swallowing difficulties. Swallowing is just something that happens for most people without having to think about it, but dysphagia can affect all people of all ages,

By: Adele Janel Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl February 20, 2012 lViews: 171

Parents who bring their child to me for Speech Pathology often tell me that they have looked dyspraxia up on the internet, but there are so many different terms that seem to be used it becomes very

By: Adele Janel Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl February 12, 2012 lViews: 165

Literacy - acquiring reading, writing, and spelling - is one of the most complex things we do. This article gives an overview of all the different processes that need to happen, all at the same time,

By: Adele Janel Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl February 12, 2012 lViews: 173

As a Speech Pathologist, I often see children who are not learning to talk as well as they should. Sometimes it quickly becomes apparent that these children can be diagnosed to be somewhere on the

By: Adele Janel Health & Fitness > Speech Pathologyl February 12, 2012 lViews: 154