Author Box
Articles Categories
All Categories
Articles Resources

New York Gets To Keep Its Broken Housing Market

May 18, 2012 | Comments: 0 | Views: 177

New York City has, without a doubt, the most dysfunctional housing market of any large city in America. A lot of New Yorkers like it that way - and it looks like they will be able to keep their broken system for the foreseeable future.

If you live someplace where normal forces of supply and demand govern housing, you may be surprised to learn that New York tenant advocates were quite pleased when Mayor Michael Bloomberg recently declared that his city is experiencing a housing emergency. This "emergency," defined in this case as a vacancy rate in rental housing of less than 5 percent, has existed continuously since 1969.

In most other places, such a tight housing market would have long ago been brought into balance by some combination of rent increases and new construction. The two are related. Rent increases would prod some tenants to look for cheaper housing outside the five boroughs, and it would encourage more development of new housing stock by boosting economic returns for landlords.

But under New York's 1969 Rent Stabilization Law, so long as the city continues to face a housing emergency, it can set maximum permissible rent increases for about 1 million apartments, according to The New York Times. (1)

The Supreme Court recently declined to hear a case that challenged the constitutionality of the rent stabilization law. The court had, somewhat unexpectedly, asked for some additional information before ultimately deciding not to proceed with the case. This led to some brief speculation that the longstanding rent controls might be in danger.

The challenge was brought by James D. Harmon, Jr., and his wife Jeanne Harmon, the owners of an Upper West Side brownstone, who found themselves in a housing emergency of their own. With three of their six tenants paying below-market rates thanks to rent stabilization, the Harmons said they were struggling to pay their mortgage and property taxes.

Besides limiting rent increases, the law generally requires landlords to indefinitely renew leases for tenants in rent-stabilized apartments and, in some cases, it allows tenants to pass those leases on to family members. The Harmons argued that this violates the Fifth Amendment injunction that private property cannot "be taken for public use, without just compensation." The government essentially took control of the Harmons' property for the purpose of setting up a public housing program, subsidized at their expense, Richard Epstein, a professor of law at New York University, contended in an editorial supporting their case. (2)

Economics and logic might favor the Harmons' argument; case law, however, does not. The Second U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against the Harmons, saying that they knew what they were getting into when they acquired the building in 2005. The building had been in the family for years at that point, but the Harmons took out a $1.5 million mortgage in order to buy out another family member's share.

New York's regulations sustain the very housing crisis they are supposed to address. This is why New York, almost alone in this country, is a place where prospective tenants, rather than landlords, routinely pay broker's fees. It is also why building superintendents and others can get away with illegally demanding "key money" from prospective renters.

But a bad law is not the same as an unconstitutional one. Rent stabilization falls into the category of bad but constitutional, at least under existing precedent.

We have a long history in this country of regulating the terms of private commerce. As far back as the Colonial era, the then-colonies had strict usury laws, setting maximum interest rates that lenders could charge. Since then, various levels of government have involved themselves in a wide assortment of private dealings, from wartime rationing to government-set taxi fares, to prices on insurance policies. Rents are likewise fair game for government regulation. The Supreme Court has affirmed this on multiple occasions, including Block v. Hirsh (1921), Pennell v. City of San Jose (1988) and Yee v. City of Escondido (1993).

A real challenge to rent control laws would rewrite our understanding of the Fifth Amendment and would change how the government interacts with business. Such a change is not inconceivable. I think there is a good chance that the Supreme Court will take a serious look at land-use and zoning laws in a way that might dramatically redefine the relationship between property owners and government. I would not read too much into the court's refusal to take on the Harmon case; the conservative justices who are most likely to be interested in revisiting Fifth Amendment jurisprudence might be looking for a more clear-cut instance of injustice than one brought by an attorney who owns an expensive Manhattan brownstone.

Until and unless the high court rewrites the law in this area, New York is going to have to deal with its housing emergency, or choose not to deal with it, on its own. Courts are not in the business of striking down laws merely because they reinforce the very problems they are supposed to address.

Sources: 1) The New York Times, "U.S. Supreme Court Declines to Hear Suit Challenging the Rent Stabilization Law" 2) The Wall Street Journal, "Rent Control Hits the Supreme Court "

For more articles, please visit the Palisades Hudson Financial Group LLC newsletter or subscribe to the blog.



Source: EzineArticles
Was this Helpful ?

Rate this Article

Article Tags:



James D Harmon Jr


Jeanne Harmon




Michael Bloomberg


New York City


Rent Stabilization

Thus, you can apply for the negligence compensation under such circumstances in order to recover your loss, Negligence Claims, Negligence compensation Involvedness of Negligence Claims. The court

By: Simon Liva l Legal > Personal Injury l December 13, 2012 lViews: 292

If a lawyer is not able to devote enough time to your case then your defense is likely to suffer. Moreover specialization in one stream or other of defense is important so that the attorney can

By: Simon Liva l Legal > Criminal Law l December 12, 2012 lViews: 429

Filing a business bankruptcy can be a complex and critical task, but you have several options. You can consult your bankruptcy attorney to know which among those options is right for you.This is a

By: Harvard McIntosh l Legal > Corporations LLC l December 11, 2012 lViews: 235

You can always check for the treatments that are covered. This is because there are some policies which do not give you claims if you meet any kind of head injury.You can always check for the

By: Simon Liva l Legal > Personal Injury l November 05, 2012 lViews: 241

In Colorado, you have many Personal Injury Lawyers to choose from. When you choose the Law Offices of Andrew C. Bubb you instantly put years of experience and legal know how in your corner. Attorney

By: Dilshad l Legal > Personal Injury l October 25, 2012 lViews: 389

If you have been charged with a crime, speak with Boulder criminal defense attorney Steven Louth immediately to protect your rights. Steven Louth is a criminal defense attorney and criminal trial

By: Dilshad l Legal > Personal Injury l October 18, 2012 lViews: 244

This article explains a quiet title action. It also explains the steps how to do the action for this kind of legal action.

By: Andrea Averyl Legal > Real Estate Lawl June 12, 2012 lViews: 205

One of the best ways to improve your situation is to hire a foreclosure attorney as soon as you default on your mortgage. This ensures that your lawyer has enough time to get your situation back on

By: Abraham Avotinal Legal > Real Estate Lawl June 04, 2012 lViews: 189

The thought of owning a home is a dream come true for many people. However, some people experience a lot of trouble along the way and could benefit from a real estate lawyer.

By: Abraham Avotinal Legal > Real Estate Lawl May 30, 2012 lViews: 168

A landlord lawyer can help to solve different problems. See what options that they can provide.

By: Abraham Avotinal Legal > Real Estate Lawl May 29, 2012 lViews: 176

For many individuals, buying their first home is difficult because of the need to save up enough money to make the initial payment or to cover the closing costs. However, you may be able to use funds

By: Jake C Santosl Legal > Real Estate Lawl May 23, 2012 lViews: 248

Help for Washington homeowners facing foreclosure. the Washington Foreclosure Fairness Act went into effect in July 2011. Mortgage mediation negotiations for homeowners in default on their mortgage

By: Dave Riderl Legal > Real Estate Lawl May 20, 2012 lViews: 216

Bipartisanship isn't always sweet. Especially when it comes to the politics of sugar.

By: Larry M. Elkinl News & Society > Politicsl July 09, 2012 lViews: 237

Cashless tolling speeds drivers on their way. The big hitch is when rental car customers get an after-the-fact surprise.

By: Larry M. Elkinl Travel & Leisure > Car Rentalsl June 11, 2012 lViews: 181

Europeans, sick of their economic ills, try for a political second opinion. Will Americans do the same in November?

By: Larry M. Elkinl News & Society > Internationall May 11, 2012 lViews: 172

Sen. Marco Rubio's revised version of the Dream Act could improve GOP prospects with Hispanics. It's also good legislation.

By: Larry M. Elkinl News & Society > Politicsl April 26, 2012 lViews: 195

The economy suffers when banks concentrate on collecting fees rather than deposits. And on making trades rather than loans.

By: Larry M. Elkinl News & Society > Economicsl April 24, 2012 lViews: 208

President Romney serving with Vice President Biden? It really could happen.

By: Larry M. Elkinl News & Society > Politicsl April 23, 2012 lViews: 177

Discuss this Article

comments powered by Disqus