Author Box
Articles Categories
All Categories
Articles Resources

Homeschoolers and Public Sports

February 14, 2012 | Comments: 0 | Views: 129

Many parents who decide top homeschool their children do so knowing that many factors go into their decision, one of which is that their children would not be able to participate in the sports offered in public schools. Tim Tebow the popular quarterback who was homeschooled and allowed to play on his high school football team where he excelled and went on to great things at the university of Florida has inspired homeschoolers to try to play sports in their area. There is even a bill in Richmond Virginia named for him the Tim Tebow law if passed, House Bill 947, will allow homeschoolers to play sports at a public school.

But it is not that easy there are many people who would object to homeschoolers that are allowed to play public sports alongside students who need to meet certain grade and behavior requirements to play. They even suggest forming their own leagues and teams or joining other associations outside of public schools, church groups, YMCA, or other athletic clubs. Many parents of public school students question the fairness and hypocrisy of wanting their children on public school teams, these parents spurned the school because it was not good enough for their children and now only want to participate in certain aspects.

Of course the standard rebuttal for this argument from homeschooling parents is that they pay taxes too and have the right to play on public school teams. This is quite possibly the most overstated argument when discussing this issue and is demeaning to the homeschool movement. There are many people who pay taxes and do not have children yet they do not receive a refund, many people go years without needing police or firemen, yet they do not receive refunds for what they do not use. So claiming that you pay taxes is not an argument for why your children deserve to be involved in public school sports. It is also not a constitutional right that you are allowed to play sports. For example, in 1996, a New York appellate court ruled against a homeschooler whose local school district denied him access to interscholastic sports. The court held that, "[P]articipation in interscholastic sports is merely an expectation and no fundamental right is involved..." Bradstreet v. Sobol, 650 N.Y.S.2d 402, 403 (A.D.3 Dept 1996).

Referring to other case precedent around the country, the Supreme Court of Montana decided that "participation in extracurricular activities was not a fundamental right." (supra. 1316) The court was unable to conclude "a private school student's interest in participating in public school extracurricular activities is more important than the school district's policy decision... that it needs to restrict participation to those students who are enrolled in the public school system." Kaptein v. Conrad School District, 931 P.2nd 1311, 1317 (Mont 1997).

While the debate for homeschoolers to play public sports will be decide by local laws, we must keep in mind that these are children and if we are to deny them the right to play in the public schools we need to afford them every opportunity to play in organized sports it would be unfair to close a door without opening another one.

For more information on homeschooling or would like to visit some great Homeschool conventions Visit GHC

Source: EzineArticles
Was this Helpful ?

Rate this Article

Article Tags:

Public Sports


Play Sports


Home School

For gaining entrance in coveted fields in a reputed University, the entrance examinations are the gateway. The purpose of these entrance examinations is to test the potential of a candidate and how

By: Sarkariexam l Reference & Education > Science l December 23, 2012 lViews: 519

Competition is increasing at an alarming level in every sphere. The students have to focus completely on their studies to ensure that they get admission in the line of their choice. What more, the

By: Sarkariexam l Reference & Education > Continuing Education l December 14, 2012 lViews: 1443

'How hard is a PhD'? Many PhD holders have been asked this question millions of times, but there is never any definite answer. We look at those who walk around proudly with a 'Doctor' title with

By: onlineedublog l Reference & Education > Continuing Education l November 11, 2012 lViews: 283

In this fast paced world which is sadly recession struck, it is indeed a good idea to work while acquiring further education. A master’s degree is obviously better than a bachelor’s in almost

By: onlineedublog l Reference & Education > Online Education l November 04, 2012 lViews: 262

An Online Degree Program in Finance is gaining popularity as it helps students to develop a lucrative career. It helps in a competitive business world. This has resulted in more number of students

By: Matthew l Reference & Education > Online Education l October 31, 2012 lViews: 287

Supporting justice is one of the reasons many people get into a career in the legal field. All-inclusive Online Associate’s Degree in Legal Studies assists many in the beginning stage of employment

By: Richard l Reference & Education > Online Education l October 26, 2012 lViews: 221

One of the keys to winning big scholarships is to write really great application essays. The problem with application essays is that they have to be technically perfect, self-reflective essays. I

By: Lee Binzl Reference & Education > Home Schoolingl June 18, 2012 lViews: 188

Your student may be interested in both the local public university and the expensive private one across the country -- which one is actually cheaper?! When it comes to comparing colleges, it's

By: Lee Binzl Reference & Education > Home Schoolingl June 18, 2012 lViews: 213

Spring and summer generally offer more opportunities to go to a home educator's conference or convention. You can spend a good bit of time and money at these events. When you prepare ahead of time

By: Maggie Daill Reference & Education > Home Schoolingl June 14, 2012 lViews: 164

I have homeschooled my kids from Day No. 1. Sometimes people ask me why I do this, and my initial thought is along the lines of, "Why wouldn't I?" Plenty of valid reasons exist to homeschool.

By: Gwen Nicodemusl Reference & Education > Home Schoolingl June 14, 2012 lViews: 184

As a homeschooler, how do you demonstrate that your kids "get" what they have learned. Sure you can have them take a quiz or test, but there has to be a better way, right? There is. Notebooking.

By: Bekki Saylerl Reference & Education > Home Schoolingl June 13, 2012 lViews: 160

Visiting colleges is an absolutely critical part of your student's decision of where to attend. While it is an investment of money and time, it will save you money in the long run. There's nothing

By: Lee Binzl Reference & Education > Home Schoolingl June 10, 2012 lViews: 169