Author Box
Articles Categories
All Categories
Articles Resources

The Exceptions In The Hague Convention

January 25, 2012 | Comments: 0 | Views: 273

1. Consent

If the petitioning parent is proved to have consented to the child being taken to live in the new jurisdiction, this will act as a complete defense in a Hague case.

The key to the consent inquiry is the petitioner's subjective intent. In many cases a parent allows a child to be taken out of the habitual residence and then there is a dispute as to whether the permission was for a temporary visit or permanently. In such cases it is critical to focus on what the petitioner actually contemplated and agreed to in allowing the child to travel outside its home country. The burden of proof rests with the respondent to establish that the petitioner harbored a subjective intent to permit the respondent "to remove and retain the child for an indefinite or permanent time period."

2. Acquiescence

Acquiescence by the left-behind parent is also a defense to a Hague petition, but it is far harder to prove than consent. It requires formalities, such as testimony in a judicial proceeding, a convincing written renunciation of rights or a consistent attitude of acquiescence over a significant period of time.

3. Child's Objections and the Hague Convention

Another exception is that the child objects to being returned and has attained an age and degree of maturity at which it is appropriate to take account of its views. For this exception, there is a two-fold test:

i) Does the child object to being returned to its place of habitual residence; and

ii) Has the child obtained an age and degree of maturity at which it is appropriate to take account of its view?

In assessing the maturity level of the minor child, the court must consider the extent to which the child's views have been influenced by an abductor, or if the objection is simply that the child wishes to remain with the abductor.

There is no defined age at which the Convention considers children sufficiently mature enough for their views to be taken into account. It depends entirely on the child.

4. One Year and Settled

It is also an exception that more than one year has elapsed from the date of the alleged wrongful removal or retention to the date that a Hague case is commenced, and that the child is now settled in the new environment.

Many courts in the United States, but not in other countries, have ruled that if a child has been concealed so that the left-behind parent does not know where the child is located the one year period does not start to run until the parent learns of the child's location.

5. Human Rights Exception to the Hague Convention

Another possible defense is that the return of the child "would not be permitted by the fundamental principles of the requested State relating to the protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms." This provision was intended to deal with the rare occasion when the return of a child would utterly shock the conscience of the court or offend all notions of due process, but it is almost never utilized by the courts.

6. The Grave Risk of Harm Exception in the Hague Convention

Article 13(b) of the Hague Convention provides that a court is not bound to order the return of the child if the petitioner establishes that there is a grave risk that his or her return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an intolerable situation.

The grave risk of harm "defense" is raised in almost every Hague case but it is successful only in a handful.

The language of the exception is extremely loose. Since a parent who takes a child away from the other parent invariably has a reason to blame that parent, counsel for a respondent is always required to consider the exception and often there is enough evidence to at least make out a viable claim. On the other hand the exception requires proof of "grave risk" by clear and convincing evidence.

The trend in recent years has been to allow the defense on a somewhat more liberal basis than before.

Contact Mr. Jeremy D. Morley if you are in need to get help for New York divorce and international child abduction.

Source: EzineArticles
Was this Helpful ?

Rate this Article

Article Tags:

International Child Abduction


Hague Convention


International Family Law

Thus, you can apply for the negligence compensation under such circumstances in order to recover your loss, Negligence Claims, Negligence compensation Involvedness of Negligence Claims. The court

By: Simon Liva l Legal > Personal Injury l December 13, 2012 lViews: 291

If a lawyer is not able to devote enough time to your case then your defense is likely to suffer. Moreover specialization in one stream or other of defense is important so that the attorney can

By: Simon Liva l Legal > Criminal Law l December 12, 2012 lViews: 429

Filing a business bankruptcy can be a complex and critical task, but you have several options. You can consult your bankruptcy attorney to know which among those options is right for you.This is a

By: Harvard McIntosh l Legal > Corporations LLC l December 11, 2012 lViews: 234

You can always check for the treatments that are covered. This is because there are some policies which do not give you claims if you meet any kind of head injury.You can always check for the

By: Simon Liva l Legal > Personal Injury l November 05, 2012 lViews: 240

In Colorado, you have many Personal Injury Lawyers to choose from. When you choose the Law Offices of Andrew C. Bubb you instantly put years of experience and legal know how in your corner. Attorney

By: Dilshad l Legal > Personal Injury l October 25, 2012 lViews: 389

If you have been charged with a crime, speak with Boulder criminal defense attorney Steven Louth immediately to protect your rights. Steven Louth is a criminal defense attorney and criminal trial

By: Dilshad l Legal > Personal Injury l October 18, 2012 lViews: 243

A family lawyer provides expertise in issues relating to you, your spouse and your children. These attorneys can help with divorces, child custody, and much more.

By: Anna Woodwardl Legal > Child Custodyl April 25, 2012 lViews: 202

In the middle of a child custody battle, you need all the help you can get. Your divorce lawyer should be able to provide you with all the right legal assistance and support, and that may include a

By: Brian D. Perskinl Legal > Child Custodyl April 23, 2012 lViews: 214

I personally have done something that very few men have ever done. I legally and ethically eliminated $23,000 in back child support debt.

By: Marvin Towlerl Legal > Child Custodyl April 22, 2012 lViews: 190

Parents don't have to be forced to follow a generic visitation schedule provided by the court if they can create and agree on their own schedule. Learn how to customize a visitation schedule for your

By: Kelly A Turnerl Legal > Child Custodyl April 18, 2012 lViews: 250

Children's lives become busier as they grow older. How are divorced parents supposed to share their child's time when the child is barely home at all?

By: Kelly A Turnerl Legal > Child Custodyl April 16, 2012 lViews: 337

Paternity law deals with the legal acknowledgement of a man and their child. This will be based on several factors and isn't half as straight forward as it may at first seem.

By: Katy A Perryl Legal > Child Custodyl April 10, 2012 lViews: 199

International clients are now more frequently recognizing that a prenuptial agreement must often be drafted with a view to its potential enforceability in several jurisdictions. The potential

By: Jeremy D Morleyl Legal > Family Law and Divorcel February 21, 2012 lViews: 135