Author Box
Articles Categories
All Categories
Articles Resources

Aquinas' Proof of God

June 17, 2012 | Comments: 0 | Views: 169

Was Aquinas' proof of God sufficient? What was written by Aquinas on faith and reason is well known. Aquinas sought to reconcile faith and reason. I recently re-read his treatise again, with an eye to discover what arguments he used to prove the existence of God? I subsequently asked myself if his arguments and five proofs of God are convincing or not. Thomas Aquinas, in his famed work, "Summa Theologica", set out to prove the existence of God. His entire argument was framed with three inquiries, namely:

(1) Whether the proposition "God exists" is self-evident?

(2) Whether it is demonstrable?

(3) Whether God exists?

After careful research I discovered that in the comprehensive argument, Aquinas turned to the prime sources of his day; quoting the Bible, the Last of the Greek Fathers, Saint John Damascene; the Philosopher, known to be Aristotle; The Roman statesman and philosopher, Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius; to Augustine, and also referenced Aristotle's "Metaphysics". He leaned on the work of these men to prove the existence of God.

Herein, we will briefly discuss the validity of the final, most pertinent inquiry, as it pertains to the question of God's existence. In Article 3, Aquinas answers the question, "Whether God exists?" Accordingly, Aquinas claims, "The existence of God can be proved in five ways." These are known as Aquinas' proof of God or his five proofs of God.

As pages four and five of "Summa Theologica" disclose:

"The first... is the argument for motion."

"The second... the nature of efficient cause."

"The third... possibility and necessity."

"The fourth... the gradation to be found in things."

"The fifth... the governance of the world."

Upon close examination, I find Aquinas' proof of God to be better rhetorical instruments than actual proofs for the existence of God. They appear to be different facets of defense, but are all predicated on a single argument. Plainly put, 'If we trace all things back to their source, we'll arrive at God.' Be it "a first mover," "a first efficient cause," "the existence of some being having of itself its own necessity," "something which is to all things the cause of their being," or some intelligent being "by whom all natural things are directed to their end." This is the pattern of thought for each argument presented in his five proofs of God.

Interestingly, another common thread proving the oneness of this argument is seen dangling in the first three proofs. The phrases "this cannot go on to infinity," "it is not possible to go on to infinity," and lastly, "it is impossible to go on to infinity" are used in the respective five proofs of God. Logically, this argument sounds correct, but it still remains a singular argument, not a proof of the existence of God.

That Aquinas was grasping for straws is evident in his use of another clever rhetorical device, a blatant application of epistrophe. Notice how he ends each of the paragraphs outlining his proofs with the same phrasings:

1. "and this everyone understands to be God."

2. "to which everyone gives the name of God."

3. "This all men speak of as God."

4. "and this we call God."

5. "and this being we call God."

Was this what everyone and all men speak of and know as God? Surely, the very argument itself proves the opposite. The phrase is meant to present a unified front on the issue. It's like the modern 'Global Warming' debate in which proponents of the theory of man-caused warming argue, 'The science is conclusive,' or 'scientists agree', attempting to convey a broad, finalized consensus. Surely, the clerics, bishops, and proponents of the Christian faith agreed that everyone and all men naturally arrive at God as the source of all; however, this did not conclusively prove their claims.

Although I believe Aquinas was sincere in his beliefs and defense of the faith, I find his arguments for the existence of God wanting. Aquinas' proof of God endeavor to prove the existence of God; however, proof is much more tangible than mere arguments and reasoning. Logically speaking, yes, there must be a source of all things. Outside the realm of logic, though, proving the existence of such a source proves to be more challenging.

True to the dominant cultural norms of his time, Aquinas' proof of God subordinates all logic to the authority of the Bible. His paradigm was rooted in the book. His five proofs of God disallowed any further inspection, and were presented as proofs, when in fact they were mere arguments. Arguments, I might add, as valid, or invalid as those which sought to prove that God does not exist.

Curtis Bradley is the father of three and a full time writer and entrepreneur, residing in Connecticut. He holds a B.S. Finance, Summa Cum Laude, from Sacred Heart University (Fairfield, CT). Curtis is an avid reader and enjoys learning immensely. Currently, he's reading through his list of the top books of all time and writing extensively.

Source: EzineArticles
Was this Helpful ?

 
0
 
0
 
Rate this Article
 vote(s)
Feedback
Print
Re-Publish

Article Tags:

Five Proofs Of God

,

Aquinas Proof Of God

,

Aquinas On Faith And Reason

,

The Existence Of God

Rather than blame others, take personal responsibility to reduce our dependence on oil by using less of petroleum derived products. Repeatedly we are hearing about oil spills, rising prices on oil

By: Kyles Humphrey l News & Society > Energy l October 17, 2012 lViews: 234

Traditional analysis of debt and deleveraging (the process where households, corporations and governments are forced to reduce their overall debt) is often biased and incomplete. Opinions of how to

By: Ben Esget l News & Society > Economics l August 11, 2012 lViews: 296

In this high paced digital age, it's easy to become displaced from the people and places around you. However, it's important to support your community and your neighbors who live in it, and work hard

By: Monai Gupta l News & Society > Politics l July 11, 2012 lViews: 332

In a bold, unpredictable move, President Obama declared on Monday his desire to extend the Bush-era tax cuts for all but the highest-income earners, by which he means anyone richer than Al and Peg

By: Scott Spiegel l News & Society > Politics l July 10, 2012 lViews: 228

Bipartisanship isn't always sweet. Especially when it comes to the politics of sugar.

By: Larry M. Elkin l News & Society > Politics l July 09, 2012 lViews: 237

In a direct reflection of the financial market's currently unsteady nature, the wholesale energy markets tumbled to a four-month low at the end of May. The bearish market was thanks to the continuing

By: Graham N Paul l News & Society > Energy l July 09, 2012 lViews: 222

A history-changing discovery in Bosnia-Herzegovina has been the focus of the largest inter-disciplinary archeological project since 2005. Dr. Osmanagich explains the significance of finding the first

By: Sam Semir Osmanagichl News & Society > Anthropology Sociologyl June 27, 2012 lViews: 204

With the evolution of self awareness in human beings, we have been conferred with the ability to voluntarily regulate our sexual activities. We are expected to act prudently and pragmatically but we

By: Mahesh C Jainl News & Society > Anthropology Sociologyl June 26, 2012 lViews: 201

Philadelphia Eagles quarterback, Donovan McNabb recently proclaimed that African American quarterbacks receive "greater scrutiny" than their white counterparts do. Having raised the question on

By: Anthony K Tatel News & Society > Anthropology Sociologyl June 25, 2012 lViews: 201

With the establishment and operation, after World War Two, of reputable international organisations, and the sporadic formation of temporary coalitions of concerned nations to offer safety to

By: Raja A Ratnaml News & Society > Anthropology Sociologyl June 25, 2012 lViews: 200

I was once asked to list three great inventions that changed the world. Considering the many inventions that I've learned about over the years, I find the most influential to have been printing with

By: Curtis D Bradleyl News & Society > Anthropology Sociologyl June 25, 2012 lViews: 296

Empires, which involve absolute control by one people or nation over others, vary in both nature or structure and in their lifespan. What may be the determinants in play?

By: Raja A Ratnaml News & Society > Anthropology Sociologyl June 24, 2012 lViews: 208

If it's ok for a black comedian to make a joke about White People's Day on a major U.S. holiday like the 4th of July, Independence Day, then it should be equally ok for a white comedian to make a

By: Curtis D Bradleyl News & Society > Politicsl July 07, 2012 lViews: 200

I was once asked to list three great inventions that changed the world. Considering the many inventions that I've learned about over the years, I find the most influential to have been printing with

By: Curtis D Bradleyl News & Society > Anthropology Sociologyl June 25, 2012 lViews: 296

What are the basic ideas of Islam and what were the contributions of the Muslim Golden Age? The basic ideas behind the religion of Islam are fivefold. These five things are more than mere concepts.

By: Curtis D Bradleyl News & Society > Anthropology Sociologyl June 17, 2012 lViews: 177

In a recent discussion of politics, a friend asked me if I knew what signs of trouble appeared during the Pax Romana that weakened Rome. I had an idea about the decline and fall of Rome, but he

By: Curtis D Bradleyl Arts & Entertainment > Humanitiesl June 14, 2012 lViews: 270

What was the crisis of the Third Century" and how did Emperors Diocletian and Constantine respond to it? Simply put, the crisis of the Third Century was the end of the Roman Empire. After AD 212, the

By: Curtis D Bradleyl Arts & Entertainment > Humanitiesl June 14, 2012 lViews: 289

The complete story of Rome must take into account the result of empire-building for the Roman Republic. As the Romans grew more comfortable with their form of government, and the aristocrats more

By: Curtis D Bradleyl Arts & Entertainment > Humanitiesl June 13, 2012 lViews: 249

Discuss this Article

comments powered by Disqus